A young lady named Sylvia is considering becoming emancipated from her home at 16. Her reasons for the change include a lack of personal freedom, a small room she has to share with her sister, and the fact that her boyfriend is in college. Choose a side on the issue, and persuade Sylvia (who may be a friend of yours if you wish) to or to not seek emancipation from her home.
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
Don't do it Sylvia! Brenda Golyshevskaya
Monday, January 23, 2012
Caleb Davis
First Sylvia should finalize her emancipation because it would lead to massive gains in personal freedom. In other words if she were to legalize her emancipation then she could finally get to follow her impulses without being restricted by controlling parents. Many times it has been said that “A lifetime of peace of mind can almost always be found when acting upon sudden urges or feelings.” Just as this proverb explains Sylvia could achieve a lifetime of peace of mind if she were allowed to act upon her own urges or feelings, something that she cannot do if she were to stay with her parents. The process of legalizing her emancipation would be a smart decision because she would finally be able to discover the true happiness that awaits her if she could follow her sudden desires.
Second Sylvia would at last be able to escape the stressful confines of a sibling infested bedroom, and enjoy the relaxation that comes from sharing a room with her college boyfriend. In other words if she were to legalize the emancipation she could move out of her current room and instead into one with her beloved boyfriend. In fact, a detailed survey conducted in 2011 showed that girls who were between the ages of 16 and 21 were, on average, able to get two additional hours of sleep each night over girls of the same age if they were allowed to sleep with their boyfriends rather than siblings. Since Sylvia’s age directly correlates to that of the girls in the study, it would stand to reason that if she were not sharing a room with her sister but instead sharing a room with her boyfriend, she would gain about two more hours worth of sleep every night. Sylvia should legalize her emancipation because it would grant her the freedom to sleep with her boyfriend, thus bringing her more sleep each night.
Third if Sylvia went through with the emancipation she could spend more time with her boyfriend. This means that without the restriction of parents Sylvia would be able to be with her boyfriend as much as she wants. This is great because according to a study taken by the United Parenting Foundation of America, “Teenage daughters are 20 times less likely to make dumb choices when in the company of their boyfriends.” Based off this study it is quite clear that if Sylvia were permitted to spend an increased amount of time with her lover she would, in turn, make better decisions than if she were in the company of family. The legalization of Sylvia’s emancipation is a positive thing which would allow her more time to spend with her boyfriend, ultimately improving her judgement.
In conclusion, Sylvia should absolutely go through with the emancipation because she would be able to gain personal freedom, have a more relaxing room, and be able to spend more time with her college boyfriend. With an increased amount of personal freedom Sylvia would become more at peace with herself. Also by being able to not share a room with her sister but instead her boyfriend she would be able to sleep longer each night. Finally more time with her boyfriend would result in better judgement. So, in order for Sylvia to live a more healthy lifestyle she must legalize her emancipation as soon as possible.
Karissa Jurgens
Emma LeFevre :)
I do not think that Sylvia should seek emancipation from her home because, she has kind of lame reasons, she would have no place to live, she needs to learn to deal with difficult people, and she would have no money.
First she has lame reasons. having to share a room with your sister is not that bad. I think that Sylvia should set boundaries in her room that her sister is not allowed to pass. Also, having to share a room is no reason to seek emancipation from her home. She should learn to share a room because in college she will most likely have to share a room, along with other times in her life. Next, just because your boyfriend is in college does not mean that you have to move out. You can still see him and talk to him and text him and stuff It's not like your totally cut off from him. And if he is in college he could be 24 and she is 16 that's kind of weird!
Second, Where would she live? If she is planning on living with her boyfriend she might have to think again. If he lives on the college campus then they probably won't let her. Also, what is she suppose to do while he is in his classes? If she does not live with him who else would she live with? She might be able to live with one of her friends but that would have to be with one whose parents agree with what she did, otherwise they would probably just tell her to go home and deal! And I guarantee you that most parents will probably not agree with what she did. and the reasons that she did it.
Third, she really should learn to deal with difficult people, because in the course of her life there will be lots of people that she does not like or does not agree with, that she will have to associate with. What is she going to do if she Does not like something that the manager of her job does? quite? once when someone I know was working at JC Penny's the new manager told them that they had to go through the entire store and re-price everything so if something was $17.99 they had to re-price It to $18.00 And all of the stickers had to be perfectly straight. then they had to change all the red clearance tags to blue clearance tags and make sure they were straight. She did not agree with the manager but she freak out, no she did what he said even though she didn't like it. So If Sylvia never learns to deal with annoying people how will she ever be able to go through life without quitting jobs, moving out of apartments, and freaking out at people? She has to learn this skill
Last, how would she get money? Even If she had a job how would Sylvia be able to pay for all the things that she needs such as, clothing, shoes, food, bills, shampoo, conditioner, and all the other things we as humans need? A 16 year olds job will not be able to pay for all of these things. Also, 16 year olds usually are not able to tell the things that they need from the things that they want. For example, she may want the pair of $200.00 boots that are super cute and $50.00 off but does she need them...no she does not.
As you can see Sylvia should not seek emancipation from her home, because she has lame reasons she would have no place to live, she needs to learn to deal with difficult people, and as far as money is concerned...she would have no money. These four things are just some of the reasons that Sylvia should stay and live at home.
Paige Bergstrom
One reason Sylvia should become emancipated is for the gaining of her well-deserved privacy. For her whole life, she has been forced to share a tiny bedroom with her younger sister Hannah. Once while Sylvia was stying the night at my house, Hannah raided her personal belongings and read her private journal. Nothing Sylvia does seems to gain her any privacy, which isn’t just annoying, but rude also. Hannah also always claims Sylvia’s clothes for her own and wears them whenever she pleases. This obvious lack of respect has resulted in almost no privacy at all. In order for Sylvia to regain her privacy, she needs to be emancipated.
Another reason Sylvia should emancipate herself is so she can obtain her freedom. Her parents are very strict and keep a close eye on their daughter. And as good as this is, it also means close to zero freedom. Last weekend, Sylvia’s boyfriend wanted to take her out on a nice date. Unfortunately, her parents thought otherwise. She instead had to stay at home for no apparent reason. If Sylvia were emancipated, she wouldn’t have had to put that weekend to waste and she wouldn’t have her parents dully make decisions such as this one for her. Sylvia should emancipate herself to gain her personal freedom.
Lastly, Sylvia being emancipated would help her become more prepared for when she’s out of high school. Numerous responsibilities would be added which she wouldn’t otherwise have. For example, she would have to pay for everything herself. Food, shelter, transportation, etc. Her parents wouldn’t be to provide for her so she would have to provide for herself, similar to the real world and how her life will be like in a couple years anyway. Sylvia should emancipate herself so she can better prepare herself for the future.
In conclusion, I think Sylvia should emancipate herself from her home so she can fain privacy, freedom, and preparation for her life after high school. Having close to no privacy right now, Sylvia definitely deserves some. On top of this, she’s also lacking any personal freedom whatsoever which would surely increase her fun and social life. With added responsibilities, Sylvia would have a better look into the real world and how it really is to be an adult. Being emancipated would certainly be a good experience for her to benefit and learn from.